December 18, 2017
ESPN President John Skipper resigned today, acknowledging a long-term substance abuse problem. His announced departure also quickly revealed another stain on the culture of contemporary journalism.
Yes, you have the typical online soreheads who are irritated at the perceived political climate of the Worldwide Leader. They are virtually celebrating Skipper’s exit. Some of those people would throw a party for an animal’s death.
More disturbing is how certain media members and the Twittersphere are already rushing to judgment that something more sinister is behind Skipper’s decision. The recent rash of sexual misconduct issues of media personalities and executives quickly led the instant opinion crowd to put two and zero together and have them equal four.
The immediate condemnation of Skipper with wagering that another story will follow in his case with no proof of such is an embarrassment to our profession. True, journalism is a profession in which its practitioners are trained to be skeptical to a fault. Wading through the spinners and the carefully-crafted public relations statements is part of the job.
However, drawing unsupported conclusions in the name of opinion and commentary or outright boorishness when a man’s reputation is at stake is the epitome of irresponsibility. We seem to have an epidemic of that in today’s journalism culture.
I am not now nor have I ever been the faculty advisor to our student newspaper at Union University. As a practicing journalist for the bulk of my adult life, I do offer consulting help on occasion.
More than a decade ago, a student-athlete was suspended from the women’s basketball team and ultimately left the university. At the time, we were between journalism professors. An adjunct advisor was hired for the semester. Suspicions on the part of some students was that the student was caught with some variety of drugs. Despite various efforts to ferret a confirmation of those conclusions, none was forthcoming.
I cringed when I saw a line in a paragraph in the story which read: “We contacted The Jackson Police Department but were told no arrest had been made.” I asked to step into the once-a-week afternoon practicum of the newspaper staff. My question was simple: do you have any proof, written or verbal, that the athlete was suspended from school because of drugs? After a few stammers, the admission was that no confirmation existed. My response: then why did you raise the issue that you contacted the Jackson Police Department and received no information of an arrest?
The editor-in-chief of the paper sheepishly grinned as he said: “I thought it was something that needed to be addressed.” I then posed a hypothetical to him: if someone said to you that the president of this university was embezzling money and you could not gain confirmation of it, would you do a story on that just because you felt it needed to be addressed? “You would find yourself more than vulnerable to a libel suit,” I told him.
If more to the story of John Skipper’s resignation exists, no doubt that will be revealed in time. His and ESPN’s credibility would take a sharp blow.
However, if his decision to step down is, in fact, strictly because he needs help to cure a substance addiction, then unsubstantiated questions are being raised that create potentially libelous damage to the man’s reputation.
Assuming Skipper is opting to focus on fighting his addiction, he should be celebrated for acknowledging the problem and getting help. To go public and admit his illness may indeed be a major step toward conquering the problem.
The sad truth is that in today’s media—-especially the largely-unfiltered and unedited social media, we have some elements who can’t wait to stomp with a size 14 boot on one’s head. That’s not journalism. That’s arrogance and vulture commentary. That has no place in a medium designed to inform, educate and provide viewers and readers with a barometer to make better decisions. Yet, we wonder with astonishment why the cry of “fake news” spreads faster than the California wildfires.
John Skipper photo: ESPNMediaZone
Ethics graphics: RTDNA